Checking a product? Scan it with the free Securicode app.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Wine and spirits

Wine fraud: how fake wine works and how to protect your brand

Wine fraud: how fake wine works and how to protect your brand (cover)

TL;DR

Wine fraud is selling wine as something it is not: a fake label on cheap wine, a genuine bottle refilled, a vintage changed, or genuine stock diverted into markets it was never meant for. It costs EU wine producers an estimated €530 million a year in lost sales, and spirits producers €740 million (EUIPO, 2016).

Public cases show the stakes. Penfolds has won court cases against the copycat Rush Rich in Australia and China, including an award of RMB 70.56 million reported in February 2026, and China seized more than 75,000 cases of counterfeit alcohol in June 2026. The best protection combines a code that breaks when the bottle is opened, case and pallet tracking, and a simple way for buyers to check.

What is wine fraud?

Wine fraud is any deliberate misrepresentation of a wine to the person buying it. That covers outright fakes, but also quieter tricks: a cheaper vintage dressed up as a great one, or genuine wine sold through channels the winery never approved.

I founded Koonara Wines in Coonawarra in 1992, and I have spent more than 30 years in the Australian wine industry. The reason wine is such an easy target is simple. Most buyers cannot tell a fake by taste, the bottle is the brand, and a good bottle is easy to copy.

What are the main types of wine fraud?

Most cases fall into four groups.

TypeHow it worksWhat helps
Counterfeit labelsCheap wine is bottled under a copied or lookalike labelA code only the brand can create, checked by the buyer
Refilled genuine bottlesEmpty bottles from bars and restaurants are collected, refilled and resealedA code on the capsule that breaks when the bottle is opened
Relabeled vintagesA lesser year or wine is relabeled as a sought-after vintageItem-level codes tied to vintage and batch records
Gray market diversionGenuine wine is sold outside its authorized market or channelCase and pallet codes linked to each shipment

Lookalike brands sit alongside these. They copy the name or style closely enough to confuse buyers without copying the label exactly.

How big is the wine fraud problem?

Good numbers are scarce, so use the official ones. The EU Intellectual Property Office estimated that counterfeiting costs EU wine producers about €530 million in lost sales a year (2.3% of sales) and spirits producers about €740 million (4.4%), in a 2016 study.

Across all products, counterfeit and pirated goods were worth an estimated US$467 billion in world trade in 2021, up to 2.3% of imports (OECD and EUIPO, 2025).

About the "20% of wine is fake" claim

You will see this figure often. It is not reliable. It traces to an unofficial 2013 French newspaper estimate about the value of top Bordeaux and Burgundy fine wine, not all wine, and Wine Spectator called it almost certainly an overestimate. We do not use it.

What happened in the Penfolds Rush Rich cases?

Penfolds, owned by Treasury Wine Estates, is known in China as Ben Fu. A company called Rush Rich used the same Chinese name on its own wine. The legal fight has run for years and is a matter of public record:

  • 2017: Shanghai police seized 14,000 bottles of fake Penfolds
  • 2019: the Federal Court of Australia found Rush Rich infringed the Penfolds and Ben Fu marks and ordered A$375,302.34; the company was later forced into liquidation
  • 2020: a Nanjing court awarded RMB 1.2 million in a separate copycat case and recognized Ben Fu as a well-known mark
  • 2022: China's Supreme People's Court upheld the invalidation of Rush Rich's trade mark for bad faith
  • February 2026: an appeal court was reported to have ordered RMB 70.56 million (about US$10.2 million) with double punitive damages

These are wins, and they took years and a large legal team. Trade marks stop lookalike brands. They do not prove that one particular bottle on a shelf in Shanghai is genuine.

What other cases show the scale?

In June 2026, Chinese authorities seized more than 75,000 cases of counterfeit alcohol, a reminder that fake wine and spirits are run as businesses, not hobbies.

Fine wine has its own famous case. In the United States, wine dealer Rudy Kurniawan was sentenced in 2014 to 10 years in prison for making and selling counterfeit bottles of rare wine. Prosecutors said he blended cheaper wines, bottled them in old bottles and applied fake labels.

Why are wine exporters to Asia so exposed?

Distance and long chains. Once a container leaves Adelaide, it may pass through an importer, a distributor and several wholesalers before a bottle reaches a shelf. Each step is a chance for fakes to be mixed in, or for genuine stock to be diverted.

Australian wine exports to mainland China were worth A$728 million in the year to March 2026, down 29% (Wine Australia). Even after a fall, that is a large market, and premium Australian labels are well known in it. Empty bottles of famous wines also have resale value, which feeds refilling.

Gray market trade adds to the blur. A 2017 estimate suggested Australian wine sales to China could be up to 35% higher than official figures because of parallel trade. That figure is dated, but the pattern is familiar to exporters. We cover it in more detail in parallel imports explained.

How can you tell if wine is fake?

No single check is conclusive, but buyers can look for warning signs:

  • A price far below what the wine normally sells for, or an unusual seller
  • Labels with blurry print, spelling errors or different paper and colors from a known bottle
  • Capsules or corks that look disturbed, reglued or mismatched to the producer and vintage
  • For Australian exports, a label that does not appear in Wine Australia's public label search
  • An authentication code that fails, or shows scans in places the bottle could not have been

What does the Wine Australia Label Directory do?

Since 1 June 2021, Australian exporters have had to upload label images to Wine Australia's Label Directory before an export approval is granted. The public search tool, ELISS, works in English and Simplified Chinese, so a buyer in China can check whether a label was legitimately exported.

It is a useful check against lookalike and invented labels. It cannot tell a buyer whether a copy of a genuine, approved label is on a genuine bottle, which is where an item-level code helps.

Where should an authentication code go on a bottle?

On the capsule or closure, where opening the bottle damages it. A Securicode placed across the capsule breaks when the bottle is opened, so an empty bottle cannot be refilled and sold again with a working code. That deals with refilling at the point of sale and later, when empties are collected.

Because Securicode is phone-scannable at 1.2mm, it fits on a capsule top or neck without changing the label design. It can be printed on labels or applied by your existing printing setup.

How do case and pallet codes help?

Each bottle code can be linked to its case, each case to its pallet, and each pallet to its container. Scan the pallet and you know what is on it. Scan a bottle in a market you never shipped that pallet to, and you know which shipment it came from. See item to container tracking.

This is the part that changes conversations with distributors. Instead of suspecting diversion, you can show where it happened.

What should a winery do first?

  1. Pick the wines most at risk: icon wines, export lines and anything sold through long distributor chains
  2. Check your labels are in Wine Australia's Label Directory and tell export buyers how to search it
  3. Add a closed-loop code to the capsule so it breaks on opening, and link bottles to cases and pallets
  4. Tell buyers in your export markets how to scan and what a genuine result looks like
  5. See Securicode for wine and spirits, or apply for access to start with one wine

Key takeaways

  • Wine fraud covers fake labels, refilled bottles, relabeled vintages and gray market diversion
  • EUIPO estimated losses of €530 million a year for EU wine and €740 million for spirits (2016)
  • The "20% of wine is fake" figure is not reliable
  • Penfolds' cases against Rush Rich show trade marks stop copycats but take years
  • A code on the capsule that breaks on opening deals with refilling
  • Linking bottles to cases and pallets shows where diverted stock came from
DR

Dru Reschke

Founder, Securicode

Dru founded Securicode after more than 30 years in the Australian wine industry, where he saw first-hand how counterfeit and gray market stock damage a brand. He is the inventor named on Securicode's patents.

Frequently asked questions

How common is fake wine?

Nobody has a reliable global figure. The best official estimate is EUIPO's: about €530 million in lost EU wine sales a year (2016). The often quoted "20% of wine is fake" figure is not reliable.

How can I tell if a bottle of wine is fake?

Check the price and seller, the print quality of the label, and whether the capsule or cork has been disturbed. For Australian exports, search the label in Wine Australia's ELISS tool. If the bottle carries an authentication code, scan it and check where else it has been scanned.

What is refilling in wine fraud?

Genuine empty bottles of well-known wines are collected, refilled with cheaper wine and resealed. A code placed across the capsule so it breaks on opening stops the empty bottle carrying a working code.

Does a trade mark protect my wine from counterfeits?

A trade mark lets you take legal action against copycats, as Penfolds did. It does not let a buyer check that one specific bottle is genuine, which is what an item-level code does.

Make every product provable

Apply for access to create Securicodes for your brand, or book a demo and we will show you a live scan.